Removing paragraph (g) from the best interests duty (BID) is meant to make scaled advice easier to deliver. Whether it also makes advice cheaper depends on how a practice is built, according to a licensee and an adviser, who look at the question from different parts of the market.
The paragraph at issue is the so-called catch-all in the BID safe harbour that asks advisers to take “any other step” that would “reasonably be regarded” as being in a client’s best interests. The government announced on 19 August that it will remove only the broadest safe-harbour step {paragraph (g)} and Professional Planner has reported a lawyer’s warning that the reform may not boost scaled advice.
For Nick Hilton, executive general manager of advice delivery at Entireti, one of the country’s largest licensee groups, the opportunity is price. For Courtenay Walker, head of advice at Sydney firm Fox & Hare, which includes scoped advice in an annual membership, removing paragraph (g) would leave what her clients pay unchanged. Where the two meet is the file: neither expects it to get any shorter.
Two views on price
Hilton expects advisers to be “more comfortable in building a scaled advice proposition without necessarily having to have (g)”, and to price it accordingly. “It won’t be as expensive as what a comprehensive piece of advice is,” he says. Entireti advisers have a minimum fee averaging about $4,500, “because that’s what it’s costing them”. If advisers can more easily deliver scaled advice, he says, “some savvy advisers” will work out they can give good advice “at a price point that [clients are] willing to pay”.
Walker sees it from a different starting point. Fox & Hare advises 20-to-45-year-olds through annual membership packages. Initial advice is “always holistic”, she says, and scoped advice is offered to ongoing members as part of the membership fee. “We’re not going, ‘okay, you want advice on just investments, we’re going to charge X for that’,” she says. Asked whether she would change her pricing model if (g) were removed, she said no.
Nor does she see paragraph (g) as a large cost in her own practice. “I don’t think step (g) is a really big cost driver from a process or a scaling perspective.” Where she finds it difficult is its vagueness: “If we were to get taken to court, I have no idea, honestly, whether we would pass that or not.” Day to day, she says, the other safe harbour steps “do a really good job of telling us what we need to do”, and (g) “maybe captures the 1%”.
Her uncertainty reflects how little guidance exists on what (g) demands on its own. Paul Derham, of Holley Nethercote, told Professional Planner he was not aware of a single case in which an adviser who had done everything else right was caught out on (g) alone. For Hilton, the test arrives more often through complaints, judged with “the benefit of 20/20 hindsight”.
Walker’s view reflects how her firm is set up. She expects a business built around scoped advice “would have a really robust process around it”, and says Fox & Hare “could do the same”. For her own practice, she says, the barriers to reaching more clients lie “elsewhere”.
Common ground: the file
On the file, the two see it the same way. “I don’t think it’ll change too much in terms of the file,” Hilton says. “Good record keeping is good record keeping. I don’t know that I’d want to categorically say now you don’t have to keep detailed records of your interactions with your clients. I think that’s always going to be a requirement.” Walker agrees that files won’t get any shorter because record-keeping stays a requirement.
They also agree that narrowing the advice doesn’t narrow the work. Even if a client “wants a specific piece of advice, well, you’re really required to investigate everything in relation to (g) so that you can actually determine that scaled advice is appropriate for that client”, Hilton says. “So you end up having to do half the work anyway.” Walker describes the same thing in her practice. “Whether we’re scoping or not, we’d be getting all the same information,” she says. “So from a cost perspective there’s no difference, because the work and the breadth of the work is going to be exactly the same.”
Hilton links that to the catch-all. He compares advice with other professions: an accountant asked to do a tax return doesn’t first consider your trusts and other entities, and a lawyer asked about a family law matter doesn’t work through your estate. In financial planning, he says, the safe harbour and its catch-all mean an adviser has to consider everything. Advisers “can, but they haven’t typically” scaled their advice, partly because advice can be viewed differently with hindsight once a complaint arises. “There’s always this category of ‘you should have thought of something else’.”
What happens next
Hilton expects the change to arrive in stages. Removing (g) would be “the first step”, he says, but it has to start with the legislation, because ASIC “will always say it’s not their job to write legislation”. Then comes guidance. “Inevitably the legislation just provides you with one data point,” he says. “It’s really then the reg guides come in, which really describe how ASIC is going to interpret the legislation,” and that is what licensees need to make more informed decisions. “That’ll just take some time.” Licensees provide guidance and templates, he says, but “fundamentally, the scope of the advice that’s being generated is at the discretion of the adviser.”.
The government has said it will remove (g) while keeping steps (a) to (f) and the best interests duty itself. If paragraph (g) goes, Hilton says, “I think we’ll actually see a larger number of advisers developing, and we would be supportive of developing more of a scoped and scaled advice proposition.” He expects that to reach clients: “more consumers getting advice because it’ll be priced at a point that they can afford”. If the changes get through in the form people are expecting, “I think it’ll be a good outcome for the industry.”
Walker’s practice is already set up to offer scoped advice within a membership, so she sees less change ahead for her own pricing. How the removal of (g) plays out on price may depend on which of those two models an adviser runs.


















Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Login via LinkedIn