The end of easy markets is when advice proves its worth

For much of the past decade, strong markets have done a lot of the work for investors and their advisers. Interest rates were low, money was cheap and a handful of big themes carried portfolios a long way, so it was understandable for clients to judge advice by the numbers on their statements.

In our view, that period is coming to an end. Markets increasingly reward evidence over stories and, with the cost of capital rising, investors have grown less patient with companies that cannot show a return on what they spend. We remain constructive on markets over the long term, but the easier part of the cycle is behind us.

The rules are changing at the same time, with super balances above $3 million now facing additional tax on their earnings, changes to capital gains tax taking effect from July 1, 2027, and a new minimum tax on discretionary trusts on the way. For many families, the structures they have built their wealth around are being rewritten, and the uncertainty alone has many of them holding back until they can see where the settings will land.

For advisers, this combination matters more than any single market call. When returns are harder to come by and the rules keep moving, clients start asking whether they are still on track, a question that returns alone cannot answer and one that we believe shows what advice is really worth.

In our experience, the biggest risk to a family’s wealth is rarely the market itself and far more often the decision made in reaction to it.

This is particularly true for business owners who have recently sold, whose wealth has moved from one asset they knew inside out to a portfolio they did not build, often spread across super, a family trust and their own names. A weak quarter can tempt them to retreat to cash and a change in the rules can tempt them to restructure in a hurry, yet either decision, made in haste, can cost more than the market fall or tax change that prompted it. Helping clients avoid those decisions never appears on a performance report, but it is often the most valuable work an adviser does.

There are also risks that no portfolio report captures. Families may live longer than planned or lose a family member earlier than expected, relationships break down, legal claims arise, and a business may need capital at short notice or an exit may come sooner than anyone anticipated. These are often the risks that determine whether a family reaches its goals, and very few of them have anything to do with markets.

That changes where an adviser’s time is best spent. Good advice in this environment is as much about managing risk across the whole family group as it is about managing a portfolio, which means spending less time explaining performance and more time understanding what each part of a family’s wealth is there to do, how much risk the family can afford to carry and what happens to the plan if something goes wrong. It also means having the difficult conversations with clients before markets turn or the rules change, so that the family has a plan in place before it is needed.

Good advisers have always worked this way, but the difference now is that clients are more likely to notice. In a rising market almost every portfolio looks fine and almost every adviser looks capable, whereas in a more demanding one the gap between advice built around products and scale and advice built around a family’s goals becomes much easier to see.

What clients need in this environment is not more products but more clarity. The firms that provide it and can explain its value, are likely to deepen their client relationships through the next cycle, while those that have relied on markets to do the work may find the coming years more challenging.

Markets may no longer do the heavy lifting, but for advisers who do this well, that is exactly when the value of their work becomes most apparent.

Kane Baranow is the director and principal at Hamilton Wealth Partners.

Leave a Comment

Intrafund advice bill looms as Mulino takes aim at ‘pension boost’ products

Intrafund advice bill looms as Mulino takes aim at ‘pension boost’ products

The government will introduce intrafund advice bill next week Assistant Treasurer and Minister for Financial Services Daniel Mulino told the ASFA conference. The bill is set to clarify the boundaries of the intrafund advice.

Sort content by