Shield, First Guardian fallout to continue into 2027

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission will intensify scrutiny of private credit markets and managed investment schemes in 2027 as the fallout from the $1.2 billion collapse of the Shield and First Guardian master trusts continues. 

ASIC chair Sarah Court will unveil nine enforcement priorities for 2027 at the regulator’s annual forum in Sydney on Wednesday. According to speech notes seen by Professional Planner, Court will target broader issues exposed by the funds collapse including harmful financial advice and lead generation models, misconduct in private credit and managed investment schemes, and failures by auditors and other professional gatekeepers. 

“Our seventh priority is holding to account those responsible for the collapse of the Shield and First Guardian Master Funds,” Court is expected to announce.  

“This work is unfinished and its scale and complexity will continue to demand substantial enforcement attention. 

“Investigations are continuing, and further civil or criminal action will be considered where the evidence supports it.” 

Since the Shield and First Guardian master funds collapse, which resulted in at least $1.2 billion loss of retirement savings, ASIC has issued bans – some permanent – on several advisers and AFSLs that were involved in the collapse. 

ASIC’s fifth priority focuses on the adjacent issues of misconduct in private credit and management investment schemes, specifically on disclosures, governance, conflicts and valuation practices. 

“ASIC’s attention will focus on disclosure, governance, conflicts and valuation practices. 

“Firms must uplift standards and improve their governance and conflict management arrangements. They need to ensure their disclosures are transparent and their valuation and reporting practices are sound,” Court said. 

On the AI and technology fronts, ASIC fourth priority will sharpen its focus on risks from technology, including automated systems that make inappropriate decisions or put barriers between customers and the help they need. 

ASIC will focus on serious failures in the way financial firms use AI and other technologies that can result in misleading information being shared with consumers, or systems that provide inappropriate decisions or prevent customers from accessing effective support and assistance. 

“Artificial intelligence, automated decision-making, and chatbots may improve the delivery of financial services, but do not alter a firm’s legal obligations,” Court said. 

“The ability to obtain human review is particularly important where customers are making a complaint, responding to a scam, pursuing an insurance claim, or seeking financial assistance.” 

Accordingly, the regulator says it will focus on poorly designed or inadequately supervised systems that produce misleading information. 

“The technology may be new. The responsibility is not.” 

During a media briefing in September, Financial Advice Association Australia chief executive officer Sarah Abood said that using predictive models could be used to help prevent disasters such as the Shield and First Guardian collapse. It can help work out “where’s the next scandal and how do we stop it before it expands to hit $1 billion and 12,000 consumers. How can we find them earlier?” 

The other enforcement priorities ASIC will announce include: 

  • Misconduct by banks, insurers, and superannuation trustees that compounds cost of living pressures; 
  • Predatory practices targeting consumers and small businesses experiencing financial difficulty, including harmful debt collection and debt management practices; 
  • Misconduct by auditors and other professional gatekeepers; 
  • Failures in obligations for financial reporting, licensing, and record-keeping; 
  • Exploitation and misuse of ASIC’s corporate registers. 

Sarah Court will give the opening address at the Professional Planner Advice Policy Summit on 23-24 February 2027 at Old Parliament House, Canberra. For more information please visit https://www.professionalplanner.com.au/topic/events/advice-policy-summit/2027-advice-policy-summit/

Leave a Comment

Scaled advice, education pathways headed for legislative fast track

Scaled advice, education pathways headed for legislative fast track

Minister for Financial Services Daniel Mulino has revealed the measures outlined in his National Press Club address in August responding to the Shield and First Guardian disaster will be split into “at least three” tranches and introduced to Parliament next year. Measures to reform education requirements for financial advisers and amend the best interests duty safe harbour will be expedited in a bid to boost access to advice.

Sort content by