Produced in partnership with Betashares.
Unlisted managed funds are bleeding money and that bloodletting is set to continue, with new research showing that unlisted managed funds outside of private assets have suffered $57 billion in outflows over the past five years.
The beneficiary of this trend has been exchange-traded funds (ETFs), which have amassed $150 billion over the same period.
For investors still in unlisted managed funds, there are a number of potential capital gains tax (CGT) consequences to consider, according to Tom Wickenden, investment strategist at Betashares.
“In an unlisted managed fund, you can’t practically stream out unrealised capital gains to people exiting so every time there is a redemption request, the manager has to sell down shares to pay out that investor and there may be capital gains consequences,” he tells Professional Planner.
“At the end of the year, those left in the fund get left with the bill.”
In addition to CGT triggered by a direct investor selling their units in an unlisted fund, investors can also incur CGT from the sale of assets inside the fund.
When fund managers buy and sell assets, and rebalance their portfolios, any net realised capital gains are passed through to investors in the fund as part of their annual trust distribution.
In recent years, Wickenden has observed a spike in distributions, which are likely linked to redemptions from actively managed unlisted funds. At the same time passive and factor-based ETFs are seeing record inflows.
“At the end of the financial year, you’re seeing some unlisted active managers make large distributions,” he says, citing distributions of around 10 per cent from “high profile managers” last financial year that had also underperformed the benchmark.
“They’re selling positions and paying out the associated capital gains. In some cases, investors have underperformed the market by 10 per cent and, on top of that, they’ve been hit with a tax bill on distributions that they probably didn’t even want because they want to defer tax obligations and keep their capital growing in the market.”
Part of the appeal of ETFs, aside from liquidity, transparency and greater accessibility, Wickenden says, is their tax effectiveness.
“ETF can much more practically stream out these internal realised capital gains to authorised participants as they redeem units,” he says.
“The same mechanism is legally available but practically impossible for managed funds.”
“As a result, managed fund investors can be left carrying the capital gains tax bill generated by those who exited during the year while ETF investors typically are not.”
A lot more room for growth
The Australian funds management industry sat close to $5tn at the end of the last financial year. Unlisted managed funds still make up a significant portion of this, around 30%, significantly more than ETFs which hold around 7%.
However, ETFs are growing rapidly in popularity. In just the past 5-years ETFs have doubled their share of the Australian funds industry.
The increasing popularity of ETFs can be attributed to effective investor education and the rise of factor ETFs. Factor ETFs track transparent rules-based indices, but instead of weighting companies by size, they select and weigh other metrics such as value, momentum and quality.
Among unlisted and active managed funds, only private assets are gathering material money, attracting around $56 billion from institutional and wholesale investors over the past five years, based on data from Betashares.
“Most of the time, we’re not seeing money flow out of unlisted active funds and into listed active ETFs, we’re seeing it flow to passive ETFs,” Wickenden says.
With the wall of money being redeemed from unlisted managed funds, investors still in those funds need to weigh up the advantages and disadvantages, and act decisively to avoid a hefty tax bill.







Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Login via LinkedIn